Motherblame-Stigma and Institutional Gaslighting

Obscuring Failures in Child Disability Care Infrastructures

Authors

  • Tammy Nyden

Abstract

Mothers of children with mental illness are on the frontlines of two global crises. The rates and severity of children’s mental illness have been rapidly growing, increasing the need for services and community supports. At the same time, four decades of privatization and austerity have resulted in what Emma Dowling calls “the care crisis,” including a state of disarray in the children’s mental health service sector. The intersection of the children’s mental health crisis with the care crisis makes it impossible for many children to access hospital beds for mental health emergencies and community-based disability services necessary to keep them alive and in their own homes. Mothers overwhelmingly bear the economic and social burdens of filling in disability service gaps. Furthermore, the very agencies charged to serve children with disabilities depend on the exploited and appropriated unpaid labour of their mothers. This article introduces the concept of “motherblame-stigma,” a social prejudice in the form of social disgrace, blame, and distrust of mothers related to a stigmatized characteristic of their child. After tracing the history of motherblame-stigma for children’s mental illness, I apply an epistemic oppression framing to illustrate how motherblame-stigma functions to prevent mothers from correcting distorted public narratives about child disability service infrastructures (a contributory injustice) and to sow self-doubt within mothers about their own experiences and capabilities (gaslighting). I provide examples of institutional gaslighting in state policy, law, public statements, and narratives to blame mothers for failing to seek and navigate services that do not exist.

Author Biography

Tammy Nyden

Tammy Nyden, PhD, is an associate professor of philosophy at Grinnell College. She is the author of Spinoza’s Radical Cartesian Mind (Continuum, 2007); the coeditor of Cartesian Empiricisms (Springer 2013); and the author of several articles on Spinoza, Dutch Cartesianism, and the history and philosophy of early modern science. She has been awarded fellowships from the Fulbright Program, The American Council of Learned Societies, the Obermann Center for Advanced Studies, and the Scaliger Institute. She is also a cofounder and codirector of Mothers on the Frontline. This non-profit organization uses feminist-informed methods and storytelling to promote children’s mental health justice, caregiver justice, and caregiver healing. She has worked on children’s mental health policy issues on boards and committees at the city, county, and state levels and won several awards including the Isabel Turner Award from the Iowa City Human Rights Commission and Iowans with Disabilities in Action Advocate of the Year.

Downloads

Published

2025-03-31

How to Cite

Nyden, T. (2025). Motherblame-Stigma and Institutional Gaslighting: Obscuring Failures in Child Disability Care Infrastructures. Journal of the Motherhood Initiative for Research and Community Involvement, 15(1. Spring / Fall), 20. Retrieved from https://jarm3.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/jarm/article/view/40718